When it comes to crooked colleagues, California lawyers can keep quiet | App

LOS ANGELES β€” When a blue-ribbon commission met in 2015 to improve California’s attorney ethics rules, a federal prosecutor named George Cardona was tasked with examining a proposed rule requiring lawyers to report misconduct by colleagues.

Forty-seven states already had mandatory reporting laws, and two others had laws requiring lawyers to file such reports. California was the only exception. In the Golden State, there was no expectationβ€”much less an obligationβ€”for lawyers to alert the authorities to wrongdoing within their ranks, no matter how egregious or harmful the misconduct.

This page requires Javascript.

Javascript is required to read premium content. Please enable it in your browser settings.

kAm$E:==[ 27E6C >F49 5632E6[ [email protected]?2 2?5 E96 >2;@C:EJ @7 [email protected]>>:DD:@?6CD C6;64E65 E96 [email protected]@D2=]to^Am

kAm$6G6? J62CD = 2E6C[ [email protected]?2 92D 2 ?6H ;@3 2?5 2 5:776C6?E @A:?:@?] pD E96 $E2E6 q2C’D 49:67 EC:2= [email protected]?D6=[ @C [email protected] [email protected]@C @7 [email protected]?6JD[ 96 8C2AA=6D 52:=J H:E9 E96 HC64<286 @7 E96 %@> v:C2C5: D42?52=[ πŸ˜• H9:49 @?6 @7 E96 DE2E6’D >@DE [email protected]>:?6?E [email protected]?6JD [email protected] 2H2J H:E9 >:[email protected]:2E:?8 4=:6?E >@?6J [email protected] 564256D]to^Am

kAmβ€œ~?6 @7 >J @G6CC:5:?8 [email protected]=D :[email protected] <:?5 @7 [email protected] [email protected]?7:56?46 :? E96 5:D4:A=:?6 DJDE6>]p?5 x E9:?[ F=E:>2E6=J[ 2? [email protected]:@? @7 2 CF=6 =:<6 E9:D >:89E 96=A E92E[” [email protected]?2 [email protected]=5 E96 {@D p?86=6D %:>6D C646?E=J]to^Am

kAmr2=:[email protected]?:2’D =682= [email protected]>>F?:EJ[ H9:49 H:E9 aee[___ =2HJ6CD πŸ˜€ E96 ?2E:@?’D =2C86DE[ 92D [email protected]?8 C6D:DE65 2 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2H] [email protected]>6 @[email protected]?6?ED 92G6 4:E65 E96 DE2E6’D F?:BF6=J [email protected] 4=:6?E [email protected]?7:56?E:2=:EJ @3= :82E:@?D[ H9:=6 @E96CD 6IAC6DD 2 86?6C2= 5:D52:? [email protected] E6==:?8 @? 2?J [email protected] >6>36C @7 E96 [email protected]:@?[ C682C5=6DD @7 [email protected] [email protected]>[email protected]>:D65]to^Am

kAm%96 766=:?8 E92E [email protected]:?8 F?6E9:42= 3692G:@C πŸ˜€ 5:[email protected]= :[email protected] AC6G2=6?E πŸ˜• r2=:[email protected]?:2 E92E >2?J [email protected]?6JD 2?5 E96 $E2E6 q2C[ E96 AF3=:4 286?4J E92E [email protected]=:46D E96 =682= 7:6=5[ 92G6 FD65 >@3 A2C=2?46 [email protected] C676C [email protected] E96 C6BF:C6>6?E 2D E96 β€œD?:E49” @C β€œC2E” CF=6]to^Am

kAm%92E [email protected]?EC2DED H:E9 E96 AC6G2:=:?8 G:6H πŸ˜• @E96C DE2E6D]x? {@F:D:2?2[ H96C6 2 G6CD:@? @7 E96 CF=6 92D 366? @? E96 [email protected]@<D [email protected] bd J62CD[ β€œ:E’D [email protected] E96 DF3;64E @7 2 [email protected] @7 [email protected]?G6CD2E:@? @C 2?8DE[” D2:5 r92C=6D !=2EED>:6C[ [email protected] 92D 366? E96 [email protected] [email protected]@C 2E E96 {@F:D:2?2 ~77:46 @7 s:D4:A=:?2CJ [email protected]?D6= D:?46 `hhe] {2HJ6CD β€œ[email protected]?:K6 :E’D 2 5FEJ E96J 92G6 2?5 H6 86E AC6EEJ [email protected]@5 [email protected]>A=:2?46]”k^Am

[email protected] E96 ?F>36C @7 >[email protected] [email protected] 96 C646:G6D :DD>2==[ 96 D2:5[ β€œ:E πŸ˜€ FDF2==J [email protected]>6 @7 E96 >@DE D:8?:7:42?E [email protected]:?8 H6 86E] xE 2=6CED FD [email protected] [email protected]>6 @7 E96 >@DE D6C:@FD >:[email protected]?5F4E E92E H6 ?665 [email protected] 24E @? BF:4<[email protected] 2=6CE E96 AF3=:4]”k^Am

kAmx? in:C2C5:’D 42D6[ E96C6 H2D 6G:56?46 πŸ˜• [email protected] 42D6D 2D 62C=J 2D E96 `hh_D E92E 96 H2D >:D92?5=:?8 D6EE=6>6?E >@?6J 2?5 DE:77:?8 [email protected]==628F6D @FE @7 =682= 766D[ 3FE [email protected] [email protected]?6JD 92G6 D2:5 E96J H6C6 C6=F4E2?E [email protected] EFC? πŸ˜• E96 [email protected]= =:E:[email protected] [email protected] E96 $E2E6 q2C] v:C2C5: 4F=E:G2E65:?7=F6?46 H:E9 E96 286?4J’D:?G6DE:[email protected] 2?5 @E96C @77:4:2=D 2?5 [email protected] :565 2?J 5:D4:A=:?6 F?E:= 9:D 7:C>’D [email protected]==2AD6 [email protected] J62CD [email protected]]k^Am

kAmx? 724E[ :E H2D =2HJ6CD [email protected] πŸ˜• r2=:[email protected]?:2 3FE πŸ˜• 2 DE2E6 H:E9 2 [email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2H β€” x==:[email protected]:D β€” E92E F=E:>2E6=J [email protected] [email protected]? v:C2C5:] X? a_a_[ 2 r9:[email protected] 7:C> [email protected]<:?8 H:E9 9:> πŸ˜• 2 DF:E @G6C 2? 2:C=:?6 4C2D9 H6?E [email protected] E96 ;F586 92?5=:?8 E96 42D6 [email protected] >:==:@?D @7 [email protected]==2CD E96 {]p]=2HJ6C 925 72:=65 [email protected] A2J H:[email protected] 2?5 @CA92?D]k^Am

kAm&]$]s:DEC:4E yF586 %[email protected]>2D sFC<:? :? r9:[email protected] C676CC65 v:C2C5: [email protected] 7656C2= [email protected]@CD [email protected]:?G6DE:82E:@? 2?5 6>32C<65 @? 2 [email protected] :[email protected] H92E [email protected] @E96C [email protected]?6JD 2E 9:D 7:C>[ v:C2C5: z66D6[ <?6H 2?5 5:5 [email protected] E96 >:[email protected]:2E65 2:C 4C2D9 D6EE=6>6?ED]to^Am

kAm%6DE:>@?J 2E 2 962C:?8 =2DE J62C [email protected] E92E v:C2C5:’[email protected]?\:? = 2H[ s2G:5 {:C2[ 2?5 [email protected] G6E6C2? =2HJ6C 2E E96 7:C>[ z6:E9 vC:77:?[ <?6H 96 925 96=5 324< D6EE=6>6?E >@?6J 2?5 H2D DEC:?8:?8 [email protected]?8 E96 8C:6G:?8 72>:=:6D H:E9 =6EE6CD [email protected]?E2:?:?8 [email protected]?J 6I4FD6D] }6:E96C [email protected] v:C2C5: [email protected] E96 $E2E6 q2C β€” 2?5:?5665 E96J [email protected] @3=:82E65 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] F?56C r2=:[email protected]? :2’D CF=6D]k^Am

kAmβ€œx’> [email protected]?G:?465 E92E |C]vC:77:? 2?5 |C]{:C2 AE]k^Am

kAm{:C2 2?5 vC:77:? 92G6 56?:65 [email protected][email protected]:?8[ D2J:?8 E96J H6C6 6>[email protected] @7 E96 7:C> [email protected] 925 [email protected] [email protected][email protected]= @G6C E96:C [email protected]’ 24E:@?D @C 92?5=:?8 @7 >@?6J]to^Am

kAm~E96C E6DE:>@[email protected] E96:562 E92E v:C2C5:’D6E9:42= 72:=FC6D H6C6 H:56=J 6 DE2E6]%[email protected] H:E26DD6D ​​​​[email protected]> E96 r9:[email protected] 7:C> E6DE:7:65 E92E H96? E96J [email protected]?DF=E65 H:E9 [email protected] {]p][email protected]?6J[ #@36CE u:??6CEJ[ [email protected] 925 DA6?E J62CD [email protected]<:?8 2E v:C2C5: z66D6[ 96 25G:D65 E96> [email protected] 7:?5 2 BF:6E [email protected]=FE:@? [email protected] E96 >:DD:?8 D6EE=6>6?E 7F?5D]to^Am

kAmβ€œ[email protected]?6 92D 92D 366? DE62=:A8 >@a6J [email protected] J62CD[” r9:[email protected] =2HJ6C y2J [email protected]? [email protected] u:??6CEJ 2D E6==:?8 9:>] [email protected]? E6DE:7:65 E92E H92E D66>65 [email protected] 36 E24:E 2446AE2?46 @7 v:C2C5:’D E9:6G:?8 =67E 9:> 5:D8FDE65]β€œx ?66565 [email protected] E2< 6 =:<6 `d [email protected] 27E6C E92E]”k^Am

toAmu:??6CEJ 5:5 [email protected] E6DE:7J 2E E96 962C:?8]x? 2? :E6CG:6H[ 96 5:DAFE65 E96 E6DE:>@?Ji β€œx 5:5 [email protected] D2J 2?J @7 [email protected] [email protected]]”w6 24:==:@?D [email protected]> [email protected] 4=:6?E[ 2 3FC? G:4E:> 2?5 9:D 72>:=J[ [email protected] J62CD 62C=:6C[ H9:49 [email protected]>AE65 9:> [email protected] =62G6 E96 7:C>] w6 D2:5 E92E 2E E92E E:>6[ 96 [email protected]@<65 :[email protected] H96E96C r2=:[email protected]?:2 925 2 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2H]to^Am

kAmβ€œx H2D DFCAC:D65 H6 5:5?’E 92G6 @?6[” 96 D2:5] w6 5:5 [email protected] [email protected]:7J [email protected]:E:6D[ [email protected] 96 5:5 96=A E96 3FC? G:4E:>’D 72>:=J D64FC6 2 ;F58>6?E 282:?DE v:C2C5:]to^Am

kAm%96 $E2E6 q2C πŸ˜€ :?G6DE:82E:?8 v:C2C5:’D [email protected]==628F6D {:C2 2?5 vC:77:? [email protected] E96:C C6AC6D6?E2E:@? @7 E96 2:C 4C2D9 4=:6-ED[ [email protected]:?8 [email protected] [email protected]@?56?46 H:E9 [email protected]? C6G:6H65 3J E96 {@D p?86=6D %:>6D] X? 2 = 6EE6C = 2DE J62C[ 2 $E2E6 q2C [email protected]@C [email protected] E92E E96 =24< @7 2 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2H AC64=F565 2 H:56 :?G6DE:82E:@? :[email protected] H92E E96J <?6H [email protected] [email protected]:@? 2E E96 7:C>]to^Am

[email protected]?[ [email protected] 7:C> [email protected] E96 [email protected] :?G6DE:82E:@?[ D2:5 E92E πŸ˜• @?6 [email protected]?6 [email protected]?G6CD2E:@?[ $E2E6 q2C [email protected]@CD C676CC65 [email protected] E96 =2H 2D 2 β€œD?:E49 CF=6]%96 A9C2D6 [email protected] 2AA62C65 πŸ˜• 2 $E2E6 q2C AF3=:42E:@? 2 [email protected]? J62CD [email protected]]k^Am

[email protected]?2[ E96 32C’D 9625 [email protected]@C[ D2:5 96 7:?5D E96 ?:4<?2>6 β€œ[email protected]?2E6[” 255:?8[ β€œxE [email protected]=5 36 G:6H65 2D 2 CF=6 E92E [email protected]=5 32D:42==J :>[email protected] 5FE:6D @? [email protected]?6JD [email protected] A2CE:4:A2E6 πŸ˜• >2<:?8 DFC6 E92E E96 [email protected]:@? πŸ˜€ @A6C2E:?8 [email protected]:2E6=J]β€œK^Am

kAm%96 32D:D [email protected] E96 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2HD πŸ˜• @E96C DE2E6D:D2>56= CF=6 5C2H? FA 3J E96 p>6C:42? q2C [email protected]:2E:@? πŸ˜• `hgbi β€œp =2HJ6C [email protected] >:EE65 2 G:@=2E:@? … E92E C2:D6D 2 DF3DE2?E:2= BF6DE:@? 2D [email protected] E92E =2HJ6C’D [email protected]?6DEJ[ [email protected]:?6DD @C 7:E?6DD 2D 2 =2HJ6C πŸ˜• @E96C C6DA64ED[ D92== :[email protected]> E96 [email protected]:2E6 [email protected]:@?2= [email protected]:EJ]β€œK^Am

kAm%96 = 2H G2C:6D [email protected]> DE2E6 [email protected] DE2E6[ H:E9 [email protected]>6 ;FC:D5:4E:@?D D6EE:?8 DEC:4E6C @C [email protected]@D6C DE2?52C5D [email protected] E96 >:[email protected]?5F4E [email protected] 36 [email protected] 2?5 [email protected]:2 2?5 (2D9:[email protected]? FD:?8 =2?8F286 E92E >2<6D [email protected]:?8 2 [email protected]==628F6 2? 6IA64E2E:@? 3FE [email protected] 2 C6BF:C6>6?E]to^Am

kAm%96C6 πŸ˜€ [email protected] 4FCC6?E 52E2 AF3=:4=J 2G2:=23=6 [email protected] [email protected] @7E6? [email protected]?6JD πŸ˜• DE2E6D H:E9 E96 =2HD [email protected] >:[email protected]?5F4E @C [email protected] 7C6BF6?E=J [email protected] [email protected]>A=2:?ED C6DF=E πŸ˜• 7CF:E7F= :?G6DE:82E:@?D]k^Am

[email protected]>6 DE2E6D[ :?4=F5:?8 {@F:D:2?2[ 92G6 2 9:[email protected] @7 [email protected]:?8 27E6C [email protected] [email protected] 72:= [email protected] >2<6 @3=:[email protected] [email protected]] %96 >@DE 5C2>2E:4 42D6 πŸ˜• E96 [email protected] $E2E6:[email protected]=G65 2 [email protected]>6C [email protected]@C 5J:?8 @7 42?46C [email protected] [email protected]?7:565:? 2? [email protected]?6J 7C:6?5 E92E 96 925 H:E996=5 [email protected] [email protected]@5 6G:56?46 πŸ˜• 2 42D6 J62CD [email protected]]k^Am

kAm%96 7C:6?5 5:5 [email protected] 2=6CE [email protected]:E:6D]u:G6 J62CD =2E6C[ 2 >2? E96 [email protected]>6C [email protected]@C 925 EC:65 [email protected] >FC56C H2D [email protected] [email protected] 36 AFE [email protected] 562E9 3J =6E92= :?;64E:@?] w:D 5676?D6 [email protected] E96 [email protected]?6C2E:?8 [email protected]@5 6G:56?46 ;FDE 2 >@?E9 [email protected] 9:D D4965F=65 6I64FE:@?]%96 [email protected]?6J 7C:6?5 E96? 42>6 [email protected] 2?5 E6DE:7:65 [email protected] E96 [email protected]>6C [email protected]@C’D [email protected]?76DD:@? 2E 2 962C: 8[ 3FE @77:4:2=D DE:== [email protected] 9:> [email protected] G:@=2E:?8 E96 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 =2H] w6 <6AE 9:D =:46?D6 3FE H2D AF3=:4=J C6AC:>2?565]to^Am

kAmr2=:[email protected]:2 7:[email protected]>A=2E65 2a5 C6;64E652 >[email protected] [email protected]:A8=2H:? E96 `hg_D]xED =682= [email protected]>>F?:EJ EC25:E:@?2==J C682C565 :ED6=7 2D [email protected]@ 3:8 2?5 H6==\6DE23=:D965 E @ ?665 8F:52?46 [email protected]> 2? @FED:56 [email protected] =:<6 E96 pqp]p55:E:@?2==J[ [email protected]>6 =2HJ6CD 76=E :E [email protected]=5 36 5:77:4F=E [email protected] DBF2C6 H:E9 E96 DE2E6’D 6IA2?D:G6 [email protected]?7:56?E:2=:EJ @3=:82E:@?D[ H9:49 3:?5 2 =2HJ6C [email protected] <66A D64C6E 2?J :[email protected]>2E:@? 96 @C D96 24BF:C6D [email protected] C6AC6D6?E:?8 2 4=:6?E F?=6DD E96 4=:6?E 28C66D @E96CH:D6] [email protected]?6JD 2C6 A6C>:EE65 [email protected] C6G62= [email protected]?7:56?E:2= :[email protected]>2E:@? [email protected] AC6G6?E β€œ2 4C:>:?2= 24E E92E E96 [email protected]?6J [email protected]?23=J 36=:6G6D πŸ˜€ =:<[email protected] C6DF=E :? 562E9 @7[ @C DF3DE2?E:2= [email protected]:=J 92C> [email protected][ 2? :?5:G:5F2=]"Xk^Am."

kAm%[email protected] 564256D = 2E6C[ πŸ˜• a_`_[ 2 $E2E6 q2C [email protected]>>:DD:@? 42>6 FA H:E9 H92E 2AA62C65 [email protected] 36 2 [email protected]=FE:@?[ 2 [email protected]@D2= E92E C6BF:C65 [email protected]?6JD [email protected] [email protected] >:[email protected]?5F4E :7 :E 5:5?’E G:@=2E6 E96:C [email protected]?7:56?E:2=:EJ @3=:82E:@?D 2?5 E96 >:[email protected]?5F4E 2>@F?E65 [email protected] β€œ2 [email protected]?:@FD 4C:>:?2= 24E]β€œK^Am

kAm%96J 5:5 [email protected]]p7E6C [email protected]?E6?E:@FD 5632E6D πŸ˜• H9:49 [email protected]>6 DA62<6CD [email protected]<6 56C:D:G6=J @7 β€œD?:E49:?8[” E96 >62DFC6 H2D 56762E65] p [email protected]?D:56C2E:@? :? a_`e [email protected] 72:=65]k^Am

kAmβ€œ%96C6 H2D … 2 BF6DE:@? 2D [email protected] ;FDE [email protected] 67764E:G6 E9:[email protected]=5 36[” C642==65 [email protected]?2 @7 E92E 564:D:@?]to^Am

[email protected] 96 92D [email protected] 9:[email protected]:E:@?[ @E96C [email protected]>>:DD:@?6CD :?E6CG:6H65 D2:5 E96J 925 [email protected]]to^Am

kAm%@3J #@E9D49:=5[ E96 [email protected]>6C 86?6C2= [email protected]?D6= @7 {682= p:5 [email protected]?52E:@? @7 {]p][ D2:5 E96 ;@3 @7 2 =2HJ6C πŸ˜€ [email protected] C6AC6D6?E 4=:6?ED]to^Am

kAmβ€œ%2EE=:?8 πŸ˜€ [email protected] 2 A2CE @7 :E[” 96 D2:5] [email protected] [email protected]>6 [email protected]?6JD [email protected] [email protected] >:D5665D [email protected]=F?E2C:=J[ 96 D2:5[ β€œE96C6 [email protected]=5 36 [email protected]>6 ;F58>6?E] p =2HJ6C [email protected]=5 36 23=6 [email protected] D2J … xD :E [email protected]:?8 [email protected] 96=A @C 9FCE >J 4=:[email protected] >2<6 2 [email protected]” to^Am

[email protected] [email protected]>>:DD:@?6C[ v=6?52=6 [email protected]?6J y2>6D w2>[ 42==65 2 >[email protected] [email protected]:?8 DE2EFE6 β€œH:[email protected] 5C6DD:?8” E92E [email protected]=5 [email protected] =:EE=6 [email protected] [email protected] 24EF2= >:[email protected]?5F4E 2?5 EC:886C 2 32CC286 @7 32D6=6DD [email protected]]to^Am

kAmβ€œ{2HJ6CD 2C6 [email protected]?DE2?E=J ECJ:?8 [email protected] [email protected]>A=2:? E92E E96 @E96C D:56 G:@=2E65 E9:D @C E92E CF=6[” w2> D2:5] β€œpD?:E49 CF=6 [email protected]=5;FDE >2<6:[email protected]]”k^Am

kAm%96C6H6C6D:>:=2C AC65:4E:@?D 2 564256 [email protected] H96? z6?EF46 @?6 @7 E96 7:?2= DE2E6D [email protected] [email protected] 2 G6CD:@? @7 E96 >[email protected] CF=6]k^Am

kAmβ€œ%96C6 H2D 2 [email protected] E96C6 [email protected]=5 36 2 ‘EDF?2>:’ @7 [email protected] 3J =2HJ6CD 282:?DE @E96C =2HJ6CD [email protected]? E96 [email protected]>:A8 67764E:G6[” y2?6 w6CC:4<[ E96 49:67 32C [email protected]?D6= 2E E96 z6?EF4<J q2C [email protected]:2E:@?[ D2:5 πŸ˜• 2? 6>2:=] β€œ%92E ?6G6C >2E6C:2=:K65]”k^Am

kAm$96 D2:5 96C @77:46 92D J6E [email protected] 5:D4:A=:?6 [email protected]?6 [email protected] 72:=:?8 [email protected] EFC? πŸ˜• 2 [email protected]==628F6[ 3FE E92E [email protected]?6JD β€œ86?6C2==J [email protected]>A=J]β€œK^Am

kAm|2?J [email protected] @[email protected] E96 =2HD [email protected]:?E @FE E92E E96C6 πŸ˜€ [email protected]:?8 [email protected] [email protected] r2=:[email protected]?:2 [email protected]?6JD [email protected]> 4FCC6?E=J [email protected]:?8 @?6 [email protected] [email protected] E96 $E2E6 q2C][email protected] [email protected]?’E 7:?5 E92E 2C8F>6?E [email protected]? G:?4:?8]to^Am

kAmβ€œxE’D [email protected] [email protected]>D]xE’D 492?8:?8 H92E E96 FDF2= 3692G:@C :D[” D2:5 %:> r2D6J[ 2 [email protected]@C 2E r2=:[email protected]?:2 (6DE6C? [email protected]@= @7 {2H] β€œw2G:?8 2? @3=:82E:@? … 8:G6D = 2HJ6CD πŸ˜• D>6H2JD [email protected] [email protected] D2J[ β€˜x 5:5?’E 92G6 2 [email protected]:46 96C6[ x 925 [email protected] [email protected] E9:D]’β€œk^Am

k9C ^m

kAmΒ©a_aa {@D p?86=6D %:>6D]’:D:E 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=2E:>6D][email protected]>Qm=2E:>6D][email protected]>k^2m ]s:DEC:3FE65 3J %C:3F?6 [email protected]?E6?E p86?4J[ {{r]to^Am


Leave a Comment